Loan Denial Rate
On this page
Overview#
Loan denial rate is the share of mortgage applications to buy a home in a place that the lender turned down. A high rate can point to buyers who are stretched relative to local prices, or to a mix of applicants further from qualifying. It says nothing about people who never applied.
Definition#
The share of home-purchase mortgage applications on properties in a tract that the lender denied. Lenders report what happened to each application, and denial is one of the outcomes they can record, alongside a loan being made, the applicant withdrawing, or the file being closed as incomplete (FFIEC LAR data fields). Home purchase is its own loan purpose, separate from refinancing and home improvement (12 CFR 1003.4).
How to use it#
The rate shows how often buyers in a place are turned down for a mortgage. Compare it with the national figure, nearby places and the metro.
High and low values
- High denial rate: buyers are often stretching to afford local prices, have thinner credit, or carry more debt. It is common where prices have risen faster than incomes. It can hold back sales even when many people want to buy.
- Low denial rate: buyers often have strong incomes, savings and credit. It can also mean buyers who expect to be turned down have stopped applying.
Scenarios
- Rising rates: higher payments push more applicants over lenders' debt limits, so denial rates often rise.
- Rising prices: when prices outpace incomes, more buyers fall short, and the rate can climb even while lending rules stay the same.
- Tighter credit: when lenders raise their standards, denials often rise first in places with more first-time and lower-income buyers.
Use cases
- Demand that can close: gauging how much of the interest in buying turns into loans.
- Affordability screen: a high rate alongside high prices and modest incomes often marks a place where buyers are stretched.
- Access to credit: finding places where buyers have the hardest time getting a mortgage.
Source: HMDA#
HMDA Modified Loan/Application Register, published by the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
Metrics
Purchase denial rate
Denied home-purchase applications as a share of home-purchase applications on properties in the tract.
Applications withdrawn by the applicant and files closed for incompleteness are counted as applications but not as denials, so they lower the rate. Loans a lender bought from another institution are not applications at all and are excluded from both sides. County, metro and ZIP figures are built from their tracts and appear on the place card, in Index factors and in exports. Choosing this metric on its own switches the map to tracts.
Purchase denial rate, change
1-yr change, in percentage points, from the year before to the most recent activity year. For example, a move from 8% to 10% is +2 points. Each end is a single year, not the pooled window. It is shown for counties and metro areas, and a place is left blank where either year had too few applications. HMDA is used from 2022, so there is no 5-yr or 10-yr change.
Considerations
- A window of up to three years. The rate pools applications from up to three years, ending in the latest year published. Rates and credit standards moved sharply in recent years, and the pooled rate blends them.
- Only filed applications count. People who expect to be turned down often do not apply, so the rate does not show how many people could not get a mortgage.
- The rate depends on who applies. A tract whose applicants are further from qualifying shows a higher rate even if lenders treat everyone the same. The public data has no credit scores or denial reasons, so it cannot compare like with like, and it says nothing about any lender's conduct.
For limitations that affect all HMDA metrics, see HMDA considerations.
For full details and limitations, see the FFIEC’s Modified Loan/Application Register.
References#
- 1FFIEC LAR data fieldshttps://ffiec.cfpb.gov/documentation/publications/loan-level-datasets/lar-data-fields
- 212 CFR 1003.4https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1003/4/
- 3Modified Loan/Application Registerhttps://ffiec.cfpb.gov/data-publication/modified-lar
Birdseye summarizes data from public and commercial sources. Each source’s publisher is the authority on its data and methods. See our Terms of Service.